post-publication review

post-publication review

A generic term for the assessment of data and conclusions, especially of drug trials, after publication in a peer-reviewed journal.
References in periodicals archive ?
Additionally, researchers are being encouraged to pre-register their studies, and the scientific community is being prodded to shift its focus away from pre-publication peer review and toward post-publication review.
Yes, these post-publication review platforms are designed for conversational back and forth, but they are also visibility arbiters.
This case highlights that transparency, access to original data and post-publication review are important to increase the probability that scientific methods and results are valid and well interpreted.
A novel departure from the traditional peer-review process is post-publication review, where the manuscript is placed online with minimal editing (Ware 2008).
A second aspect of formalising academic discussion on social media, particularly on blogs and on Twitter, is using these as tools for post-publication review of papers.
Fifty-two percent felt that single-blind review was effective, with 37% acknowledging post-publication review and 26% recognizing open review as effective.
Nonetheless, post-publication review is seen as a useful supplement to formal peer review.
An interesting development is the post-publication review whereby articles are published as received and then voted on for publication in a more prestigious electronic archive (Nadasdy, 1997).
BioWizard was designed to make scientific knowledge dynamic, enable post-publication review in an open-access forum, and resolve vital deficiencies in how scientific information is accessed, reviewed, shared, and archived.
Martin Schaad, though he certainly cannot be faulted on the thoroughness of his preparatory reading, has identified just one previous article on this novel and a couple of short post-publication reviews.
He discusses the difference between pre- and post-publication reviews, the differences between literary criticism and book reviewing, elements of good reviews (with examples), why negative reviewing should be avoided, good habits of good reviewers, and how to conduct a review writing workshop.
The unsolicited post-publication reviews have been many favorable and some extremely critical.
Full browser ?