A shift in interpretative methods is therefore necessary in order to extricate Indian texts from a pattern of hermeneutic overdetermination
that hides the complexity and diversity of Hindu thought by reducing individual concepts to one single denominator and amplifying the hermeneutic significance of a fetish and a fragment.
I begin, in this section, by making a prima facie case for psycho-physical overdetermination
, given the assumption of dualism.
"Contradiction and Overdetermination
." For Marx, translated by Ben Brewster, Penguin Press, 1969.
While perhaps hard to justify further, the intuition that overdetermination
is impossible must be respected.
[Q: How does "ingestion" as such determine overdetermination
?] On the one hand they [objects and acts] function as figures for the process of internalizing citation; on the other hand, they reflect the unassimilated persistence of the figure thus cited....
The poems uncanny tercets repeatedly ask what one is to do with the "relics" or traces of Jesus--frequently visual images fraught with tremendous symbolic overdetermination
: "Each joke is a scandalous coffin for a carpenter" (72).
Chapter 6, "The Direct Argument for Incompatibilism," appeals to examples of preemptive and simultaneous overdetermination
(which resemble Frankfurt examples in some respects) to undermine Peter van Inwagen's direct argument for the incompatibility of moral responsibility and causal determinism.
Conversely, Ferns sees dystopia as a genre with "fewer limitations" (22) because "in resisting the authoritarian aspirations of the state, dystopian dissidents may be seen as offering, at a narrative level, an embodiment of the reader's own resistance to the closure and overdetermination
which so often characterizes the traditional utopia" (22).
When the same has become the other's same, and the suffocating display of differences has led to indifference by overdetermination
, a generally attentive critic like Margaret Morse provides us--even in the absence of a discussion of Deleuzian 'virtuality'--with a can and may opener to the bearably original, infant world of the virtual.
condition (2.4) in terms of u has the form
In other words, it is precisely to the degree that the novel makes it seem as though certain acts of commentary, evaluation, and revision take place alongside the ideological real--expressed as symbolism, imagery, character systems, the disruption of cause and effect, displacement, overdetermination
, etc.--that the novel can seem to critique and to repair, to ironize and to love, to pull down and build up, to keep its historical sense and to imagine better futures.
The spurious consensus may reflect what Kahan (2006) terms "expressive overdetermination
." Kahan defines a law or policy as expressively overdetermined when it bears meanings sufficiently rich in nature and large in number to enable diverse cultural groups to find simultaneous affirmation of their values in it.