However, until 1957, no member ever dissented
on a policy vote.
will accept the decision from which they dissented
," instead of "hold[ing] on until they can pick up a fifth vote.
Justice Blackmun dissented
, for example, in California v.
Out of these cases only 117 were split decisions, meaning at least one judge dissented
Six judges dissented
from the denial of the en banc request, declaring that the role of the court "is to give affect to statutes as Congress enacts them," and explaining the "real consequences to a court's well-intentioned decision to fix Congress's mistakes.
Justices Marshall, Breyer, Douglas and Brennan dissented
How has it happened in a church where the hierarchy has spent the last two decades clarifying and reiterating its position on a wide range of disputed questions, issuing a universal catechism, and disciplining all sorts of folks who dissented
from or questioned the authority of official teachings?
Dissenting opinions: Judge Ruwe, joined by Chief Judge Cohen, dissented
While all of the judges made a strong case for the necessity of MCIs to induce improvements in rental property and to provide an adequate return on investment, two of the five New York State Appellate Division judges dissented
on the provision for a retroactive increase.
Perhaps if the dissenting Justices were focused on the value created by the extended deliberative process, and not merely on trying to serve strategic ends, they may have dissented
49) Rehearing was ultimately denied and Chief Judge Jacobs dissented
from the order denying the rehearing en banc.
from the papal encyclical Humanae vitae in 1968 and ever since the Jesuit editors have taken their distance from the Vatican, during the 1980s especially in the area of bioethics.