85) Tushnet adds that "[o]nce we realize, as we must, that some dissenters were wrong at the moment they dissented
and wrong thereafter, the story about dissent, and about how history decides who is the winner and who the loser, becomes more complicated.
Justices Brennan, Marshall, Blackmun and Stevens dissented
In this scenario, the dissenting Justice would have dissented
in the prior case.
As for Vice Chairman Roger Ferguson and Governor Ed Gramlich--they have never dissented
in four years of voting.
While examining the dissenting opinions of the Second Circuit within the time frame set for this study, (12) Judge Pooler has undoubtedly dissented
73) Chief Justice Marshall dissented
, stating that there was no compelling state interest in waiting this extended period of time.
Hines, decided before I was on the Court, had held that where a motion to dismiss made at the close of the People's case is denied, the defendant must renew the motion at the close of all the evidence to preserve the point for appeal; (9) Judge George Bundy Smith dissented
Justice Joyce Kennard dissented
in the 1993 ruling but wrote Monday's majority opinion that found Cudjo's trial lawyer, William Clark, acted reasonably by cutting short an investigation of the victim's husband and offering no evidence that he was the killer.
Of particular note, we looked at the number of times a particular justice dissented
, if that justice dissented
more frequently when certain areas of law were involved, and identified which justices dissent most frequently.
Reacting to the failure of the motion on which Yaroslavsky dissented
, MTA Chief Executive Officer Julian Burke said the subway extension will be delayed and its cost will rise because of the delay.
Of the relevant cases, only about 35% of the dissenting opinions featured a justice who dissented
Retired California Supreme Court Justice Allen Broussard, a compassionate public servant and liberal jurist who dissented
often in favor of individual rights and the environment, has died of cancer.